Skip to content Skip to footer

Independent watchdog project. Not affiliated with the State of California, DHCS or Medi-Cal Dental.

Text size
I can't smile, California

Not the State of California

Find a Director
Find a Director

Beneficiary Dental Exception

In Sacramento County, joining a Medi-Cal dental plan is not a choice. The Beneficiary Dental Exception is the one door out, written into state law for members who cannot get an appointment. Here is who it is for, exactly what it takes, and what the State's own monthly reports show about how often that door actually opens.

The short version

One door, one county, one reason

A Beneficiary Dental Exception, or BDE, lets a Medi-Cal dental managed care member in Sacramento County leave their plan and move to regular Medi-Cal Dental fee-for-service, where they choose their own dentist. It exists for exactly one reason: you could not get an appointment.

It is not a complaint, not an appeal and not a grievance. Those are routes about a decision your plan made. A BDE is about a decision your plan never got around to making, because nobody could see you.

The whole thing rests on one section of state law, Welfare and Institutions Code section 14089.09, added in 2012. The law ties the exception to mandatory enrollment. It stays in effect for as long as Sacramento members are required to join a plan, and no longer.

It is free, there is no deadline to apply, and you do not need a lawyer, an advocate or your dentist's permission. You do need to be able to say which appointment you could not get.

The law, in its own words

“The BDE shall allow a beneficiary to opt-out of Medi-Cal dental managed care and move into fee-for-service Denti-Cal where the beneficiary may select his or her own dental provider on an ongoing basis. The beneficiary shall remain in fee-for-service Denti-Cal until the time he or she chooses to opt in to a dental managed care arrangement.”

Welfare and Institutions Code section 14089.09(b)(2). Denti-Cal is the old name for the Medi-Cal Dental fee-for-service program. You will still see it in the statute and in some of the State's own BDE paperwork.

First question

Which county are you in

This decides everything. The BDE is a Sacramento County process and only a Sacramento County process, because it was built as the safety valve for a county where you are made to join a plan.

Mandatory

Sacramento County

The BDE is for you. DHCS runs Geographic Managed Care here. If you are eligible for Medi-Cal dental services you must pick one of the three plans, and if you do not pick, one is picked for you.

Because you cannot simply walk away, the law gives you the exception instead. DHCS is responsible for processing every BDE request, and for publishing a report on them every month.

The statute says the process is for beneficiaries mandatorily enrolled in dental health plans in the County of Sacramento, and that it lasts for as long as mandatory enrollment does.

Opt in

Los Angeles County

The BDE is not for you, and you should not need it. Dental managed care in Los Angeles is a Prepaid Health Plan arrangement and it is voluntary. In the State's words, a beneficiary must opt in to take part.

You joined by choosing to, so you can leave by choosing to. That is a plan change through Medi-Cal Health Care Options, not an exception process, and it does not require you to prove you were unable to get an appointment.

There is a form for it. Health Care Options publishes a Medi-Cal Managed Care Choice Enrollment Form, Dental for Los Angeles County, and describes it as the way to join or change your dental plan, or to return to Regular Medi-Cal.

Health Care Options: 1-800-430-4263TTY 1-800-430-7077. Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m.

Why the line is drawn there

An exception is only needed where there is a rule to be excepted from. Los Angeles members are in a plan because they said yes. Sacramento members are in a plan because the State said so. The BDE is the price the State pays for compelling people into a network, and the statute says so directly: it exists for as long as mandatory enrollment for dental care is in effect in the County of Sacramento.

Everywhere else in California, all 56 other counties, there is no dental managed care to leave. Medi-Cal dental is fee-for-service already, and you pick any dentist who takes it. How the two systems differ.

Do you qualify

Four clocks, and one of them has run out

The BDE form asks you to check a box. Each box is an appointment your plan was supposed to be able to give you inside a set time. If it could not, that is your reason. These are the timely access standards in the plans' own contract with the State.

24 hours

Emergency

Pain, swelling, or bleeding. If this is you, DHCS says do not mail anything. Call the BDE line and say it is a dental emergency.

Call 1-855-347-3310

72 hours

Urgent

Three days. The form words it as not being able to get an urgent appointment within 72 hours.

4 weeks

Routine

An ordinary, non-emergency visit. A checkup, a cleaning, a filling you are not in pain over.

30 days

Specialist

Counted from when the referral was authorized, not from the day you asked. The State's newest version of the form splits this in two: 30 calendar days for children and 30 business days for adults.

Who the specialists are

Standards as DHCS states them in every monthly BDE report, under the heading “Timely access requirements for appointment timeframes per the DMC contract.” The 24 hour emergency standard also appears in the State's BDE process letter. The other three are the boxes printed on the BDE request form itself.

There are two live versions of this form, and they do not say the same thing

Medi-Cal Dental publishes a BDE form with a revision date of January 2017, whose specialist box reads “within 30 days from authorized request.” Health Care Options publishes a newer one, document code MU_0003834_ENG_0925, posted in March 2026, whose specialist box reads “30 calendar days for children and 30 business days for adults.” The newer wording is the one that matches the plans' contract, which gives an adult 30 business days for an authorized specialist referral. The newer form also adds after hours guidance the old one lacks: leave a message and a representative calls back in BDE hours, and if you cannot wait, contact your dentist or go to an emergency room.

Both are live on state websites today. Both list the same phone number, email, fax and PO box, so either will reach the right desk. If you want the one that reflects the current standard, use the Health Care Options version.

There is also an “Other” box. The form ends the list with a blank line marked Other, so the four clocks are not a closed set. If your problem with getting seen does not fit one of them, write it there in your own words rather than deciding for yourself that you do not qualify.

Do not confuse these with the other deadlines

These four are about getting an appointment. They are a different set of clocks from the prior authorization deadlines, which govern how long your plan has to decide whether it will pay for treatment your dentist has already proposed. Those are 5 business days for a routine request and 72 hours for an urgent one, and missing them counts as a denial you can appeal. Two separate problems, two separate routes. The prior authorization deadlines are here.

How to ask for one

Four ways in, and none of them go through your plan

The request goes to the State, not to the company you are trying to leave. Every route below is an address at the Department of Health Care Services.

By phone

1-855-347-3310

Monday to Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. The fastest route, the only one for an emergency, and the only one where a State representative fills the request out with you.

By fax

(916) 464-3783

Addressed to Dental Managed Care BDE. Still on the form, still live, still 2017's idea of convenience.

By mail

PO Box 997413

Dental Managed Care BDE
PO Box 997413, MS 4900
Sacramento, CA 95899-7413

All four routes are printed on the State's own BDE request form and repeated in its form instructions. In the reports DHCS publishes, requests arrive roughly one third by phone and two thirds by mail, fax or email.

What the form actually asks for

It is one page. There is no medical evidence to gather, no letter to write and nothing your dentist has to sign.

  • the patient's name and date of birth
  • the Benefits Identification Card number, the BIC, copied from the card exactly as it appears
  • a best contact number, which is the one they will actually ring
  • if the patient is under 18, a parent or guardian's name, relationship, phone and email, and the parent or guardian has to be the one who signs
  • a check in one or more of the four boxes, or a note in the Other line
  • a signature and a date

Beneficiary Dental Exception (BDE) Form, revision date January 2017, published in twelve languages by the Medi-Cal Dental Services Program.

Get the real form

Take the form and the instructions from the State directly rather than from us. Medi-Cal Dental publishes its version, with instructions, in Arabic, Armenian, Cambodian, Chinese, English, Farsi, Hmong, Korean, Russian, Spanish, Tagalog and Vietnamese. Health Care Options publishes the newer English version described above.

Official BDE page and forms

The newer form

Answer the phone. This is the single most practical thing on this page, and the State's own numbers are the reason. Once your request is in, somebody will try to reach you within three business days. If they cannot, they try once more, and then the case is closed by letter. You can start again, but you start again at the beginning. The reports show how often cases end this way.

Easy to confuse

There is a second exception, and it is not this one

Sacramento's mandatory enrollment has more than one release valve. Health Care Options lists them together under one heading, which makes them easy to mix up. They are for completely different problems and they go to different desks.

Beneficiary Dental Exception

The problem: you cannot get an appointment.

Who fills it in: you do, or a State representative does it with you on the phone.

Where it goes: Dental Managed Care BDE at PO Box 997413, MS 4900, Sacramento.

If granted: you move to fee-for-service and stay there until you choose to go back.

Request for Dental Exemption From Plan Enrollment

The problem: you are midway through treatment for a complex dental condition with a dentist who is not in any plan's network, and changing dentists now would hurt you.

Who fills it in: your dentist does, and signs it. The form is addressed to them, not to you.

Where it goes: Health Care Options at PO Box 989009, West Sacramento, or fax (916) 364-0287, marked for the Research Unit.

If granted: you keep seeing that dentist on fee-for-service for the duration of the treatment plan, not indefinitely.

The second one asks a lot more of you. Your dentist has to give a diagnosis, the current or proposed treatment plan, how many months it will take, an estimated completion date, and an explanation of why a managed care plan cannot finish it. They must also state their dental license number, Medi-Cal provider number and NPI, say whether they are in any plan's network, and attach any outstanding Notices of Authorization. The form asks the dentist to confirm that disrupting continuity of care would cause, in its words, potentially deleterious results to the patient's health, or would impede access to necessary care.

So which one do you need

If the sentence that describes your problem is “nobody will see me,” you want the BDE, and you can start it yourself today with a phone call. If the sentence is “I am already being treated and my dentist is not in any of these networks,” you want the dental exemption, and the first conversation is with your dentist rather than with the State. Nothing stops you from pursuing both if both are true.

Both forms are listed together under “Exception and exemption to plan enrollment forms” on the Health Care Options download forms page for Sacramento County. Quotations are from the Request For Dental Exemption From Plan Enrollment form itself.

What happens next

The clock the State puts on itself

The statute sets out a sequence with deadlines attached, and then describes two ways it can end. This is that sequence.

  1. Day zero

    Your form arrives, or you call the BDE line. If you call, a State representative helps you submit the request there and then, and coordinates with your plan from that point.

  2. Within 3 business days

    Somebody contacts you about your request. The statute puts this duty on the department. The current DHCS web page and every monthly report say it is a representative of your dental plan who makes that call. That difference matters, and we take it up below.

  3. Within 5 business days of that contact

    They work with you and with the plan to get you an appointment inside the contract's time limits. This is the plan's chance to solve the problem instead of losing you.

  4. If no appointment is available

    The department approves and processes the exception and moves you into fee-for-service. The statute is not conditional about this. It says the department shall approve and process the BDE.

  5. If an appointment is available

    You go to it. Afterwards you get a follow-up call asking how the visit went and whether anything else is outstanding.

  6. Closing the case

    If that follow-up turns up no further access problems, the case is closed and you stay with your plan. If you never responded to the attempts to reach you, the case is closed as well, by letter, and you are free to file a fresh request.

Welfare and Institutions Code 14089.09(b)(4)

“Upon receipt of the BDE form, the department shall have no more than three business days to contact the beneficiary. The department shall, within five business days from the date of contact with the beneficiary, work with the beneficiary and the dental plan to schedule an appointment … (A) If an appointment is not available, the department shall approve and process the BDE and move the beneficiary into fee-for-service Denti-Cal.”

Ellipsis ours, covering a citation to the contract timeframes and to the Knox-Keene Health Care Service Plan Act of 1975.

The question people actually ask

Do you have to rely on your plan to get out of your plan

Short answer: you do not need its permission, and you do not apply to it. But under the process as DHCS currently describes it, the plan is the first voice you hear.

What the law says

The department has three business days to contact you. The department works with you and the plan to find an appointment. The department approves and processes the exception if there is no appointment. The plan is a party to the process, not the gatekeeper of it.

What the State's page says

“Upon receiving a BDE request, Dental MCP representative will contact the member within three (3) business days to assist the member.” If you do not respond, the plan tries once more, and then a letter closes your case. The first call, the scheduling and the closure all run through the plan.

So what should you actually do. Send the request to the State by whichever route suits you. Then treat the plan's call as the thing standing between you and an answer, because it is. Pick up. Write down who called, when, and what they offered. If they offer an appointment you can genuinely attend, that is a good outcome and your problem is solved. If the appointment is weeks outside the standard, is with a dentist who is not taking you, or never materializes, say so on the call and call the BDE line at 1-855-347-3310 to tell the State the same thing.

You are allowed to go straight to the State

DHCS says that if you use the BDE phone line, one of its own representatives will help you submit the request and will then coordinate with the plan on your behalf. That is the route with the most State involvement and the least reliance on the company you are trying to leave. It is also, on the State's own figures, the route about a third of people take.

Show your work

What the State's own reports show

The statute requires DHCS to publish, every month, the number of people requesting a BDE and the specific outcome of each request. It does. We read all twelve reports published since the current plan contracts began on 1 July 2025, and counted the outcome column.

107

BDE requests received, July 2025 through June 2026

130

Closed cases listed in those reports' outcome tables

80

Closed as “Member Non-Responsive”

0

Closed as “Unsuccessful”, the category DHCS uses when the exception is granted

What those words mean, in DHCS's own definitions

Every report carries the same three definitions. They are worth reading slowly, because only one of them is a BDE being granted.

The three outcomes DHCS records, quoted from its monthly reports
Outcome DHCS definition What it means for you
Successful “member was able to get an appointment and seen by a DMC provider” You stay in the plan. You got seen, which is what you wanted.
Unsuccessful “member was not able to get an appointment and was granted exception to FFS” You leave the plan. This is the only outcome that is a BDE being granted.
Member Non-Responsive “member was contacted and did not respond or offered an appointment with a DMC provider but did not accept the offer or attend the appointment” Nothing happens. The case closes and you are where you started.
The count

Across all twelve monthly reports from July 2025 to June 2026, we counted 130 closed cases. Fifty are recorded as Successful. Eighty are recorded as Member Non-Responsive. None is recorded as Unsuccessful.

Method: we took every row of the closed cases table in each monthly report, which DHCS publishes as Figure 3, and tallied the outcome column. Our per month totals match the sentence each report prints above its own table, so the arithmetic is DHCS's as well as ours. A closed case can have been received in an earlier month, which is why 130 closures sit alongside 107 new requests in the same window.

BDE requests and closed case outcomes by month, from the reports DHCS published
Month Requests received Cases closed Successful Member non-responsive Exception granted
July 202528315260
August 20255322390
September 202531010
October 202564310
November 202534400
December 202523210
January 202632110
February 202644040
March 202685230
April 202620171160
May 202616186120
June 202699360
Total10713050800

Compiled from the twelve monthly Beneficiary Dental Exception reports published by DHCS on its BDE reports page. Requests received is the figure each report gives in its opening sentence. The other three columns are our tally of the outcome column in each report's closed cases table.

What we are and are not saying. We are not saying anyone was refused. There is no record of a refusal in these documents, because the reports do not have a category for one. What the documents show is that in twelve months of published reporting, the route out of a plan was never the way a case ended. Cases ended because somebody got an appointment, or because the member stopped answering. Whether that reflects plans fixing access, members giving up, or a process that quietly resolves itself before the exception is reached, the reports do not say, and we are not going to guess.

One number worth sitting with

Sixty-two percent of closed cases, 80 out of 130, ended with the member classed as non-responsive. DHCS's definition of that phrase is broad. It covers someone who never picked up, and equally someone who was offered an appointment and did not accept it. Those are very different situations filed under one heading, and the reports do not separate them.

If it is granted

What changes when you move to fee-for-service

You pick your own dentist

Any dentist who takes Medi-Cal Dental, not a list of three plans' networks. The statute says you may select your own dental provider on an ongoing basis.

You do the calling

The State's own letter is blunt about it. Ring 1-800-322-6384 and Medi-Cal Dental gives you the names, numbers and addresses of three dentists in your area. Then you call them to book.

It lasts until you say otherwise

This is not a temporary pass. You stay in fee-for-service until you choose to opt back in to a managed care plan. Nobody puts you back automatically.

The benefits themselves do not change. DHCS states that covered dental services under managed care are the same services provided under fee-for-service. What changes is who you can see and who arranges it. The difference between the two systems.

Read the small print with us

What is still unclear

Four things we noticed reading these documents that we cannot resolve from the public record.

Open questions

  • Who is supposed to make the first call. The statute says the department shall contact the beneficiary within three business days. The DHCS web page and all twelve reports say a Dental MCP representative does it. We have found no document explaining when or why the duty moved, or whether DHCS considers the plan to be acting on its behalf.
  • The process letter is thirteen years old and describes a narrower program. The BDE process letter still posted by DHCS carries a revision date of March 2013 and is addressed to parents and guardians, opening with the line that in Sacramento County most Medi-Cal dental patients under the age of 21 are required to use a managed care plan. Everything else the State publishes today describes the BDE as available to Dental MCP members generally. A member reading the official letter could reasonably conclude the process is not for them.
  • The reports do not explain their own June 2025 cases. DHCS states there was no BDE reporting from December 2023 through June 2025 because members did not need an exception to move to fee-for-service in that window. Yet the July 2025 report closes 26 cases it says were received in June 2025, and the August report closes another 5 from June. We cannot reconcile those two statements.
  • There is no published category for a refusal. DHCS records three outcomes and none of them is a request that was turned down. If a request is ever declined on its merits rather than resolved or closed for non-response, the monthly reports as designed would not show it.
  • Two versions of the form are live at once. The Medi-Cal Dental site serves the January 2017 form and the Health Care Options site serves a newer one with a different specialist standard. We have found nothing telling a member which to use, and the twelve monthly reports still quote the older, looser wording of “30 days from authorized request” rather than the split the newer form sets out.
  • Health Care Options describes the BDE far more narrowly than Medi-Cal Dental does. It files the form under the title “Request for emergency dental exception from plan enrollment” and tells members to use it “if you do not want to join a dental plan because of a dental emergency.” The form itself, and everything Medi-Cal Dental publishes, covers urgent, routine and specialist appointments too. A member who reads only the Health Care Options description would reasonably think the BDE was for emergencies alone.

Two typing errors, noted for the record, because we are relying on these documents. The July 2025 report writes “Thirty-one (1) BDE requests were closed in July”, and the August 2025 report writes “twenty-two (23) were received in July”. In both cases the surrounding tables and totals make the intended number clear, and we have used the figure the tables support.

If you have been through this

We would like to hear how it actually went, especially who called you, how long it took, and what you were offered. Tell us here. We will not publish anything that identifies you.

Show your work

Sources

Everything on this page comes from the State. Go to these before you rely on us.

  1. Welfare and Institutions Code section 14089.09. The statute that creates the BDE, added by Stats. 2012, Ch. 23, Sec. 80 (AB 1467), effective 27 June 2012. Subdivision (b)(1) for the Sacramento scope and the link to mandatory enrollment, (b)(2) for the right to choose your own dentist on an ongoing basis, (b)(4) for the three and five business day clocks and the duty to approve when no appointment is available, and (c) for the monthly reporting requirement.
  2. Medi-Cal Dental, Beneficiary Dental Exception (BDE). The official member page, and the source of the form, the instructions and the process letter in twelve languages.
  3. Medi-Cal Dental, Beneficiary Dental Exception (BDE) Form, revision date January 2017. The four check boxes, the Other line, the fields and the mail, email and fax routes.
  4. Medi-Cal Dental, Form Instructions: Beneficiary Dental Exception (BDE), revision date January 2017. The emergency instruction and the BDE line hours.
  5. Medi-Cal Dental, BDE Process Letter, revision date March 2013. The four qualifying timeframes including the 24 hour emergency standard, the five business day step, and the instruction to call 1-800-322-6384 for three dentist names once you are in fee-for-service.
  6. DHCS, Beneficiary Dental Exception Reports. The monthly reports required by the statute. We used every report from July 2025 to June 2026, and that page is also our source for the statement that reporting stopped between December 2023 and June 2025.
  7. DHCS, Medi-Cal Dental Managed Care. For mandatory enrollment in Sacramento County, opt-in enrollment in Los Angeles County, the two of 58 counties figure, and benefit parity with fee-for-service.
  8. Medi-Cal Dental, Dental Managed Care Member Contact Information. For the BDE line as the number to call for appointment help, the plans' member numbers in each county, and the mailing address.
  9. Medi-Cal Health Care Options, download forms, Sacramento County and download forms, Los Angeles County. Source of the newer BDE form posted March 2026, the Request For Dental Exemption From Plan Enrollment, and the Los Angeles dental choice form used to return to Regular Medi-Cal. Health Care Options is on 1-800-430-4263, Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m.
  10. On this site: Dental managed care for how the two delivery systems differ and how Sacramento's mandatory enrollment has changed over time, and Utilization management for the separate prior authorization deadlines.

Filed one of these? Tell us what happened.

Who called you, how fast, what they offered, and where it ended up. The State publishes the totals. It does not publish what the process felt like from your side of the phone.

Share your experience